What CO2 Does in a Tank
Carbon dioxide (CO2) dissolves in water, forms a weak acid, and lowers pH. Every tank holds some. Without injection, open water settles near 2-3 ppm at equilibrium with the air (Aquarium Science), and fresh tap water can start higher or lower before it settles. Tanks operating without pressurized gas rely on atmospheric exchange, substrate breakdown, and livestock respiration, as detailed in our guide to the low-tech planted tank.
CO2 and Plants
Dissolved CO2 is the main carbon source for most aquarium plants. High-light planted tanks inject CO2 to raise it from 2-3 ppm to a target of 15-30 ppm. However, higher irradiance increases carbon uptake only when photosynthetic growth is not constrained by other limiting nutrients; review our guide to planted tank lighting and PAR before increasing injection rates. Aquarium Science gives 10-25 ppm as a desirable range and says 30 ppm is the common high-tech target (15.6). Low-tech and soil-based tanks get a modest amount from decomposing soil and fish respiration, without injection. See the CO2 injection guide and the bubble-per-second guide for equipment. Plant metabolism relies on the complementary roles of CO2, light and dissolved nutrients: when lighting and carbon rise, balanced liquid fertilizer dosing is essential to prevent nutrient exhaustion.
CO2 and Fish
More CO2 is not always better. Sources give different limits, and none is a guarantee:
- Aquarium Science: over 30 ppm can harm fish; low-stocked tanks may tolerate up to 40 ppm.
- Fish veterinarians: below 10 mg/L is well tolerated in aquaculture, with species differences (Fish Vet Group).
- A University of Florida extension sheet on fish transport rates CO2 above 20 ppm as bad (UF/IFAS EDIS, archival).
- Retailer guides report that invertebrates tend to show stress before fish (Light Fish).
Treat 30 ppm as an upper working target for planted tanks, not a safe limit for every species. Start low, increase slowly, and watch the fish.
The pH, KH and CO2 Relationship
CO2 + H2O reacts to give H+ and bicarbonate (HCO3-). With a fixed amount of bicarbonate (KH), more CO2 means lower pH. The equilibrium constant gives:
CO2 (mg/L) = 15.7 x KH (dKH) x 10^(pK1 - pH), with pK1 = 6.35 at 25 C (LSBU). The number 15.7 comes from 0.3567 meq/L per dKH times 44.01 g/mol.
Hobby charts use a simpler form: CO2 = 3 x KH x 10^(7 - pH). For KH 4 it gives 12 ppm at pH 7.0, 19 at 6.8, 30 at 6.6 and 48 at 6.4. We verified those four values. We also found that the chart's coefficient 3 is lower than the equilibrium coefficient, which is 3.51 at 25 C.
| pH (KH 4 dKH) | Chart-style estimate (3 x KH x 10^(7-pH)), ppm | Equilibrium estimate at 25 C, ppm | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7.2 | 8 | 9 | +17% |
| 7 | 12 | 14 | +17% |
| 6.8 | 19 | 22 | +17% |
| 6.6 | 30 | 35 | +17% |
| 6.4 | 48 | 56 | +17% |
| 6.2 | 76 | 89 | +17% |
The coefficient depends on temperature, because pK1 changes with it (values from a textbook table quoted on UKAPS):
| Water temperature | pK1 (apparent) | Coefficient on KH x 10^(7-pH) | vs chart coefficient 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20 C | 6.38 | 3.77 | +26% |
| 25 C | 6.35 | 3.51 | +17% |
| 30 C | 6.33 | 3.36 | +12% |
So a chart reading of 30 ppm may correspond to roughly 33-38 ppm at equilibrium in water at 20-30 C, if bicarbonate were the only buffer. The chart is still useful because drop-checker colour guidance and most hobby advice are based on it. Keep both numbers in mind, and plan fish safety around the higher one.
Chart-style estimates for common KH values (ppm CO2):
| KH (dKH) / pH | 7.2 | 7 | 6.8 | 6.6 | 6.4 | 6.2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | 4 | 6 | 10 | 15 | 24 | 38 |
| 3 | 6 | 9 | 14 | 23 | 36 | 57 |
| 4 | 8 | 12 | 19 | 30 | 48 | 76 |
| 6 | 11 | 18 | 29 | 45 | 72 | 114 |
| 8 | 15 | 24 | 38 | 60 | 96 | 151 |
Three practical points from the chemistry:
- KH does not set the CO2 level. If you change KH, pH moves but CO2 stays the same. If you change CO2, pH moves (Aquarium Science).
- For a given CO2 increase, the pH drop does not depend on KH (for KH of 1 dKH or more). A drop of 1.0 pH unit always means 10 times the starting CO2. If the degassed baseline is about 3 ppm, a 1.0 drop gives roughly 30 ppm. This "pH drop" method needs no KH value (UKAPS; 2Hr Aquarist).
- Calcareous rock can mislead pH controllers. Extra CO2 dissolves carbonate rock, KH and pH rise, and a controller may add even more CO2 (Aquarium Science).
How to Measure CO2
Drop Checkers
A drop checker is a small glass bulb with a pH indicator (bromothymol blue) in a reference solution, usually 4 dKH, separated from tank water by an air gap. CO2 diffuses in and changes the colour. Blue means low, green means near target, and yellow means too high. A 4 dKH reference solution turns green at about the pH the chart equates with 30 ppm: pH = 7 - log10(30 / (3 x 4)) = 6.6. Replace the solution on the manufacturer's schedule (a retailer guide says every 3-4 weeks).
Limits: drop checkers respond slowly and average over roughly three hours (Aquarium Science), so they miss short spikes. Because the reference solution is isolated from tank water, tannins and aquasoil acids do not affect the colour (Gensou).
pH-KH Calculation and Its Limits
You can calculate CO2 from pH and KH with the CO2 ppm calculator. The result is only valid when carbonate is the only buffer. These break it:
- Phosphates, including some plant fertilisers, fish food, and commercial pH buffers (Aquarium Science).
- Humic and fulvic acids from aquasoil, tannins from driftwood, peat, or botanical tannins in fish tanks (2Hr Aquarist; Gensou).
- KH below about 1 dKH, where test resolution is poor and other buffers dominate (UKAPS).
Measurement error also adds up. A pH error of 0.1 changes the estimate by about +26% or -21%. A KH error of 0.5 dKH at KH 4 changes it by 12.5%. Calibrate your pH meter and take both readings the same day. If your tank has aquasoil or driftwood, trust the drop checker over the calculation.
Warning Signs in Fish
Retailer guides list these signs of too much CO2 (2Hr Aquarist; Light Fish): lowered activity, hiding, laboured breathing, delayed response to food, erratic swimming, and hovering or gasping at the surface. A large pH drop and a yellow drop checker support the diagnosis. Shrimp and snails may react first.
If you see these signs: stop the CO2, raise surface agitation or add an air stone, and do a water change. Gasping also has other causes, including low oxygen and ammonia, so check those too (see fish gasping at the surface). Fish stressed by CO2 can show secondary problems later, so keep watching for a few days.
To prevent problems, start with a low bubble rate, raise it in small steps over days, and keep the drop checker in view. Check that the gas stops when the solenoid closes.
CO2 Methods Compared
The table shows the main ways to add CO2, with the sources' own limits and disagreements.
| Method | How it works | Control | Reported pros | Reported cons and safety | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pressurised cylinder | Regulator, solenoid and diffuser or reactor feed CO2 gas | Precise; solenoid can switch off at night | Stable and controllable once set up (UKAPS poster) | Failures can overdose a tank; Aquarium Science says expect occasional fish losses and advises aeration at night with moderate stocking | UKAPS; Aquarium Science; Aquarium Science |
| DIY yeast | Yeast and sugar fermentation in a bottle | Poor; output declines over days and cannot be timed | Very low cost | Unstable levels and frequent refills; never close the outlet (pressure); Aquarium Science does not recommend it | UKAPS; Aquarium Science |
| Passive bottle or jar diffuser | Small CO2 supply through a bottle or jar | Low | Simple for small low-tech tanks | Will not feed a high-light tank; suits tanks under about 20 gallons per the author | Aquarium Science |
| Liquid carbon (glutaraldehyde) | Dosed liquid disinfectant sold as 'liquid CO2' | Dose only | Algae suppression; simple | JBL calculates at most about 1.76 mg/L CO2 from 1 mL of a 4 percent solution per 50 L (about 0.7 realistic); one forum view says plants process it internally; some plants (e.g. Riccia) can degenerate | JBL; Aquarium Science; UKAPS |
Related Guides and Tools
- Carbonate hardness (KH) and pH explain the other two values in the pH-KH-CO2 relationship.
- CO2 ppm calculator computes both estimates from your readings.
- CO2 cylinder calculator estimates how long a cylinder lasts.
- water chemistry hub lists all water chemistry guides.